It’s been over a week and you are all are some of the fastest readers I know. So if you haven’t read The Wildcat’s Claw yet, you might want to go hit up another thread (unless like me you don’t having endings spoiled for you… because I’m pretty positive we’re going to talk about that ending in about ten seconds).


All right? Safe to continue?


…….


THAT ENDING. I know. I KNOW. What do you think? Is this it? Is Worthy gone? And… who is going to tell Dawson?


Okay, can’t dwell on that, too sad. What did you think of Anka and Meilin becoming friends? Wildcat’s Claw, cooler than the Heart of the Land or just different? Were you expecting everything that went down in Trunswick?


Tell me all your thoughts!!

 

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Recent threads

Wings of Fire: JMA's library /303800

Storystarter: Who are you again? /303076

Storystarter: Shadow House explanation /303077

Under the Horizon blood sand /303801

 

Need storystarters? Check out Shadow House and Horizon! 

Thumbnail avatar 29d6ade36f

hunterwolf85

first

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

(( Ł Ë Ø )

f o r u m p h a r a o h

violinist // whovian // ENFJ // slytherin // aries

"the blushing light, just another la devotee"

Utensil Police // Duck Cultist

#AllPeopleArePeople

merry christmas !!!!!

Thumbnail avatar eb5801f5ee

catdragon13873

I bet Worthy totally survived. They didn't see the body!

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Jade-

Hablo Espanol

Jade- Me 

Pineapplethe RainWing/NightWing hybrid

Bubblesplash- the warrior cat 

Bored- Meh flipside 

Pinkie Pie- the MLP character 

Peril- the firescales dragon 

Frosty- my irl cat 

Leaf- a hybrid cat

 

#threadnecromancy

 

 

*is stalking this thread so I can have spoilerz*

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 

Leafwhisker

Wolfstar

Tigerfang

Stormypaw

Lulupaw

Whitefoot

Hornetfire

Hornetflick

Daisyleaf

Winston

 

#Icewhisker!

 

I'm weird. Get used to it

 

Im insane; you?

 

*~Christian~*

  

#OnlyOneSpeshalBubbles

 

"Geoduck- it looks like a naked turtle."

Thumbnail avatar eb5801f5ee

catdragon13873

*same*

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Jade-

Hablo Espanol

Jade- Me 

Pineapplethe RainWing/NightWing hybrid

Bubblesplash- the warrior cat 

Bored- Meh flipside 

Pinkie Pie- the MLP character 

Peril- the firescales dragon 

Frosty- my irl cat 

Leaf- a hybrid cat

 

#threadnecromancy

 

 

Thumbnail avatar 31d9fcc6c6

darkwolf6599

IF I DON'T READ THE BOOKS, HOW ELSE SHOULD I KNOW?!?!?!?

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 The "Boys Club"

 

Jack-Ratchet-Jewel-Boris-Thor-Snowflight-Moonstar (My bff)-Arrowkit-Me "MUAHAHA THIS ISN'T A BOY'S CLUB ANYMORE!"

 

"You're just pure weird"-Viv

 

"Thanks."- Me to Viv

 

 

 

 

 

it was

sort of cheesy and cliché 

but the plot was interesting 

"yikes" was said three times 

but "i'm more of a vegetarian" makes up for it 

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Ever After~ 

"but laugh, laugh, laugh, hayden"

ayita, my better twin

oh christmas tree! OH CHRISTMAS TREE!

 

 

 

F E S T I V E 

Thumbnail avatar f7b3d8ccef

coindragon103

I just KNOW Worthy is ok! but when will he turn up? I bet it's in book 7: Stormspeaker.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call me Peace

My gang: Goldheart, the RainWing/SeaWing hybrid,

Peace (Me), Flame, the SandWing, Log, the MudWing, Starmaker, the NightWing, Puddle, the SeaWing, Cloud, the SkyWing, Iceberg, the IceWing,  Rollan , Tsunami, the SeaWing, Nadia, my IRL BFF

Thumbnail avatar 609e8d938d

arrogantdragon60

I loved this book! It was definitely one of the best! :) The ending though...:( Poor Worthy... I think he's alive. He has to be. They need all of the gifts, and he has the Claw. Btw, it'd be awesome if ya'll could find a way to sneak Shane back in to. He was my fav..:)

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 huge fan of 39 clues

 

i am a girl

 

extreme jesus freak

 

Go Spirit Animals!!!

Shaneke rocks!!

Thumbnail avatar b550895843

skyscraperarrow12

oh man, i swear if Worthy dies-- *PRESCREAM*

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call Me Destiny, Mai, Meanie, Dune, or Mina

?WHO AM I REALLY?

A Warrior?

A Seeker?

A Fighter?

A Greencloak?

A Hero?

A Musician?

A Reader?

A Survivor?

A Challenger?

A Normal Girl?

A Human?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The truth is...

 

I'm all of them

 

And that's who I will always be...  

Thumbnail avatar f7b3d8ccef

coindragon103

omg lol remember this funny moment?

 

Rollan: what happened? did the snake bite you?

Worthy: more like I bit it.

 

aaaaand Worthy was sptting out snake scales. LOL!

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call me Peace

My gang: Goldheart, the RainWing/SeaWing hybrid,

Peace (Me), Flame, the SandWing, Log, the MudWing, Starmaker, the NightWing, Puddle, the SeaWing, Cloud, the SkyWing, Iceberg, the IceWing,  Rollan , Tsunami, the SeaWing, Nadia, my IRL BFF

Thumbnail avatar b550895843

skyscraperarrow12

now, spoiler time

 

oh my three moons, it was so good... the first thing i learned was MEILIN CAN DANCE?!?! but then again, i guess a good warrior should also be a graceful dancer...

and i have no idea was i was laughing at Cordelia when she yelling out, "You fool! What are you doing?" at Worthy... i guess it was because i thought it was funny that she was trying to make sense out of Worthy's actions before she "dies"? did she die? i hope Worthy doesn't die, because i will prob have another breakdown like i did with Shane :P

oh and it was funny that Meilin tried to be a joker and everyone was like yelling NO to her little joke question

 

this was so out of order, and i didn't even reveal much, if you peeps want more, just ask... i can reveal more if wanted

it's funny that all the Oathbound guards who have their names, like Cordelia the Kind and Brunhild the Merry, don't actually live up to their name

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call Me Destiny, Mai, Meanie, Dune, or Mina

?WHO AM I REALLY?

A Warrior?

A Seeker?

A Fighter?

A Greencloak?

A Hero?

A Musician?

A Reader?

A Survivor?

A Challenger?

A Normal Girl?

A Human?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The truth is...

 

I'm all of them

 

And that's who I will always be...  

Thumbnail avatar b550895843

skyscraperarrow12

no idea *why

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call Me Destiny, Mai, Meanie, Dune, or Mina

?WHO AM I REALLY?

A Warrior?

A Seeker?

A Fighter?

A Greencloak?

A Hero?

A Musician?

A Reader?

A Survivor?

A Challenger?

A Normal Girl?

A Human?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The truth is...

 

I'm all of them

 

And that's who I will always be...  

Destiny, I loved all the Meilin details in this book! 

I also love that we got some good funny moments in.

I'm on the fence about Worthy's fate, and I can see other people think he might be alive... Someone convince me he's definitely dead? 

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Recent threads

Wings of Fire: JMA's library /303800

Storystarter: Who are you again? /303076

Storystarter: Shadow House explanation /303077

Under the Horizon blood sand /303801

 

Need storystarters? Check out Shadow House and Horizon! 

Thumbnail avatar 84c0c4b7d0

winterspirited29

If Worthy dies, I swear. WHAT DO THE AUTHORS HAVE AGAINST REDCLOAKS?!

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Renegade

But~She~Was~Just~Mortal

 (Backup Account)

 

 

 

 

Thumbnail avatar a44bcfd1d9

ponyspicy6

worthy definitely survived. remember he was trapped by a wall of rocks not crushed by them. the wildcats claw is as strong as diamonds so he probably is still alive and waiting for the right time to make his dramatic entrance,probably during battle.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

i am........

-a greenclock

-an agent

-the daughter of moon and qibli

-or a rainwing

-a sister

-a daughter 

-a warrior

-a student

-a bookworm

-a peace maker

-huffelpuff

-a normal girl

 

  <~snow~>

Thumbnail avatar a44bcfd1d9

ponyspicy6

i bet that there is an oathbound named ______ the mean who is going to be really nice and help the greenclocks.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

i am........

-a greenclock

-an agent

-the daughter of moon and qibli

-or a rainwing

-a sister

-a daughter 

-a warrior

-a student

-a bookworm

-a peace maker

-huffelpuff

-a normal girl

 

  <~snow~>

Thumbnail avatar 431a351bdc

icedragon791

Hmmm, the entire ceiling pretty much fell down on Worthy... it's pretty much a  mountain of debris and rocks... But come on, isn't there wildcat speed? The claw can still cut rock technically... As long as there is hope for Worthy being alive, I'm going to take it end of story. After King's death, nope. Just nope. Please no more attacking Redcloaks. 

 

Speaking of the Redcloaks, why weren't they at the battle though? Maybe they don't know where the Wildcat's Claw is, but Yumaris can sense people's locations. Did something happen to her or the army as a whole? Did they just got caught up in a battle somewhere else, or did Connor's tsunami dream from Heart of the Land come true with a tsunami passing through the Torch (like I feared)?

 

AH, I liked The Wildcat's Claw so much more than Heart of the Land, but it's making me more nervous for the Redcloaks!

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Feel free to call me Emerald or just IceDragon.

 

Occupation: Professional Ghostly Book-Nerd

#Proud Catholic

#Go RainWings, RiverClan, and Redcloaks!

 

 

 

"Good people are like candles; they burn themselves up to give others light."

Thumbnail avatar b550895843

skyscraperarrow12

@Emerald: maybe the Redcloaks are still battling with that Wikam the "Unjust" dude or maybe they're back at the Torch resting after that battle, it must have been hard for them, they were outnumbered 3 or 4 to 1 Redcloak

also, we should notice, that the "Unjust" dude and his army never appeared in the Wildcat's Claw :l

a coincidence?

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call Me Destiny, Mai, Meanie, Dune, or Mina

?WHO AM I REALLY?

A Warrior?

A Seeker?

A Fighter?

A Greencloak?

A Hero?

A Musician?

A Reader?

A Survivor?

A Challenger?

A Normal Girl?

A Human?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The truth is...

 

I'm all of them

 

And that's who I will always be...  

Thumbnail avatar f7b3d8ccef

coindragon103

Man, I hate Wikiam the "Unjust" and Corela the "Unkind". Y U DO DIS?!?!

I agree. Essix does too.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call me Peace

My gang: Goldheart, the RainWing/SeaWing hybrid,

Peace (Me), Flame, the SandWing, Log, the MudWing, Starmaker, the NightWing, Puddle, the SeaWing, Cloud, the SkyWing, Iceberg, the IceWing,  Rollan , Tsunami, the SeaWing, Nadia, my IRL BFF

Thumbnail avatar eb5801f5ee

catdragon13873

OH YEH and Brunhild the Merry, don't forget her.
  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Jade-

Hablo Espanol

Jade- Me 

Pineapplethe RainWing/NightWing hybrid

Bubblesplash- the warrior cat 

Bored- Meh flipside 

Pinkie Pie- the MLP character 

Peril- the firescales dragon 

Frosty- my irl cat 

Leaf- a hybrid cat

 

#threadnecromancy

 

 

Thumbnail avatar b550895843

skyscraperarrow12

i've been thinking about what happens when this series ends, they should write about those 4 legends: Kikimi, Gransfen & Wilco, and the other upcoming 2, and maybe Zerif's backstory too

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call Me Destiny, Mai, Meanie, Dune, or Mina

?WHO AM I REALLY?

A Warrior?

A Seeker?

A Fighter?

A Greencloak?

A Hero?

A Musician?

A Reader?

A Survivor?

A Challenger?

A Normal Girl?

A Human?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The truth is...

 

I'm all of them

 

And that's who I will always be...  

Thumbnail avatar eb5801f5ee

catdragon13873

Like Tales if the Great Beasts but with humans?

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Jade-

Hablo Espanol

Jade- Me 

Pineapplethe RainWing/NightWing hybrid

Bubblesplash- the warrior cat 

Bored- Meh flipside 

Pinkie Pie- the MLP character 

Peril- the firescales dragon 

Frosty- my irl cat 

Leaf- a hybrid cat

 

#threadnecromancy

 

 

Thumbnail avatar 431a351bdc

icedragon791

@Destiny, well that could be true. About Wikam though, it looks like the main Oathbound commander going to change for each book... but yeah, where did he go?  

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Feel free to call me Emerald or just IceDragon.

 

Occupation: Professional Ghostly Book-Nerd

#Proud Catholic

#Go RainWings, RiverClan, and Redcloaks!

 

 

 

"Good people are like candles; they burn themselves up to give others light."

Thumbnail avatar d9ae61b0a8

dogdonut473

So I think that there is a slight chance that Worthy survived. If he'd gotten out before 15 minutes was up he has almost 90% chance of survival...

And his 'death' was sort of anticlimactic, don't you think?

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 

Azilia

Travis 

Dravil

Ryan

Adam

Azalis (This is my forum name, as well as the person in control of the body)

 

Official Thread Necromancer.

Regretting all the ships that never sailed.

Thumbnail avatar 431a351bdc

icedragon791

Technically the book's beginning quote warned us about Worthy's "death," and even Abeke foreshadowed stuff when she compared Worthy to Shane, but within the battle itself, it does seem a bit out of no where. 

 

The main problem was that the Greencloaks are trapped in the cave if they don't jump off the waterfall. But if they do jump, the Oathbound would just catch them at the shoreline... but if I have to guess why it seems anticlimatic, it's because the danger level still was not clearly addressed. The actual fighting only lasted for 3 pages before Anka was being threatened. After that, Worthy started shooting fire with the Claw while the Greencloaks ran away (I don't count this as another battle scene). In those "3 pages of fighting," the main heroes and Worthy were actually handling themselves just fine anyways. It was Anka's life being threatened that made them all stop.

 

Of course, part of it is always going to feel anticlimatic for me because there's still no reason to kill Worthy off (or pretend to) other than play with our feelings. The battle could have easily been written in any other way in order to have all characters survive.

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Feel free to call me Emerald or just IceDragon.

 

Occupation: Professional Ghostly Book-Nerd

#Proud Catholic

#Go RainWings, RiverClan, and Redcloaks!

 

 

 

"Good people are like candles; they burn themselves up to give others light."

Thumbnail avatar eb5801f5ee

catdragon13873

I still think that Worthy isn’t dead. They never found the body. Basically means he’s alive. But, ultimately, it depends if the next author is a troll or not.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Jade-

Hablo Espanol

Jade- Me 

Pineapplethe RainWing/NightWing hybrid

Bubblesplash- the warrior cat 

Bored- Meh flipside 

Pinkie Pie- the MLP character 

Peril- the firescales dragon 

Frosty- my irl cat 

Leaf- a hybrid cat

 

#threadnecromancy

 

 

Thumbnail avatar d9ae61b0a8

dogdonut473

Christina Diaz Gonzales isn't a complete troll, so everything's up in the air.

But if Worthy had the Claw when he went into the cave then this book's quest failed so rip Fallen

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 

Azilia

Travis 

Dravil

Ryan

Adam

Azalis (This is my forum name, as well as the person in control of the body)

 

Official Thread Necromancer.

Regretting all the ships that never sailed.

Thumbnail avatar bbfd159b2f

iceclaws188

I need Worthy to live.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Renegade

                     and

Mercedes

Fangirl

#HammockFlavoredDrinks

Daughter of Artemis

"I wash my hands of this weirdness." ~ Captain Jack Sparrow

 

░R░e░n░e░g░a░d░e░

Teh Marvelous Lady Ash Siggy

░M░e░r░c░e░d░e░s░

 

  #ᶠᵃⁿᵍⁱʳˡᶠᵒʳᴸⁱᶠᵉ

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thumbnail avatar d9ae61b0a8

dogdonut473

Me too

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 

Azilia

Travis 

Dravil

Ryan

Adam

Azalis (This is my forum name, as well as the person in control of the body)

 

Official Thread Necromancer.

Regretting all the ships that never sailed.

Thumbnail avatar efa8113f2d

darkangel2447

Alright, I feel as though the ending was a bit rushed, so i doubt Worthy died. As for who would tell Dawson, I feel Conor should, because he knew Dawson before becoming a Greencloak. My favorite part of the book was when Anda trapped Meilin during training. I'm glad to see her combat skills have improved.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Kanna

Daughter of Athena

Follower of Hecate

Zhongese

 

Ekat 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thumbnail avatar eb5801f5ee

catdragon13873

If Worthy had the Wildcat's Claw, and he was trapped under rock, and in Heart of the Land he explicitly stated that the Wildcat's Claw could cut rock... he most likely cut himself free after they left and is being his usual Worthy self, trolling the main characters.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Jade-

Hablo Espanol

Jade- Me 

Pineapplethe RainWing/NightWing hybrid

Bubblesplash- the warrior cat 

Bored- Meh flipside 

Pinkie Pie- the MLP character 

Peril- the firescales dragon 

Frosty- my irl cat 

Leaf- a hybrid cat

 

#threadnecromancy

 

 

Thumbnail avatar b550895843

skyscraperarrow12

i think Worthy will be fine... i mean he's a good, smart kid who knows how to handle a sword by a legendary person

 

and the Oathbound? they sent their whole entire army into a cave waiting for a cave-in... in the dark, they're all stupid... no offense... beaten by 6 Greencloaks & Redcloaks multiple times, sure the heroes might have the gifts, but then again, the Oathbound could have beaten them any time to get them so... :l stupid Oathbound...

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Call Me Destiny, Mai, Meanie, Dune, or Mina

?WHO AM I REALLY?

A Warrior?

A Seeker?

A Fighter?

A Greencloak?

A Hero?

A Musician?

A Reader?

A Survivor?

A Challenger?

A Normal Girl?

A Human?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The truth is...

 

I'm all of them

 

And that's who I will always be...  

Thumbnail avatar 172bd1076e

dragonaqua2826

Loved the wildcats claw awesome and great book i read the whole thing in 20 minutes because i'm a fast reader also i'm in 4th grade

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Thumbnail avatar 6b0eb36dd4

beltrunning6

Anka and Meilin HAVE to become friends! Meilin never seemed to have the joy of female company before Abeke. 

I thought Conor would end up taking The Wildcat's Claw! Guess it goes to show that people change!

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

i may be attacked for this but i wanted worthy to die

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

fizzy

i'm going to wait for something to happen

 

 

 

I think Worthy survived. I hope he did. (When's the next book coming out, so we can find out soon?)

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

I agree, Allis.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

I think Worthy survived (I hope so!) Why did they have to make Worthy get trapped, though? Why do they do this to the Redcloaks?

 

I think Conor should tell Dawson. He knows Dawson the mostmost.

 

I'd be happy if Anka and Meilin are friends. I also like how Anka is learning those battle moves!

 

I think that the Wildcat's Claw is just different from the Heart Of The Land.

 

I wasn't expecting anything that happened...and why are the Oathbound like this?!

 

I hope the next book comes out soon!

 

 

 

 

#Greencloaks

#SpirAnimals

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

I think Worthy did survive. I think Conor should tell Dawson what happened. I think Anna and Meilin should be friends. For me, the Wildcat's Claw and the Heart Of The Land are just different. I didn't expect what happened...why are the Oathbound like that?

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

    1 ,