Well let's look at the cases for why each would or wouldn't
It seems obvious,she wanted to protect the earth and Pink Diamond would destroy it so good idea to get her out of the way! However it's just a bit too obvious and there are several holes in her shattering Pink Diamond,most brought up by Blue Zircon like how would an well known enemy get so close to an diamond? Also it's stated by Bismuth that she was shattered by a sword.I do think she had something to do with it,after all eyeball is an eye witness to it and claims she saw Pink Diamond do it.
She's the obvious choice,rushing through the trial and poofing the zircons however this could just be her way of grieving.People mourn in different ways,the more traditional way like blue diamond where there crying and sad all the time however some people grieve like yellow diamond,not wanting to think about them and being defensive and angry about it.She loves Pink Diamond she just knows she has responsibilities to homeworld and not to deal with pain plus like I said I doubt she wants to think about it.Her reasoning for shattering Pink might have been because she thought it was best for homeworld,gems needed everything for a use but the zoo was frivolous and useless for gems,she might have thought it was nessacary for the good of homeworld.That or she could just be the stereotypical 'wants to take over the world' villian but Steven Universe is too deep for that.
What? How could someone so torn up about Pink Diamond shatter her? Well greif can come from somewhere,possibly guilt? I;m not sure what her reasoning would be for doing it but it's still a possibilty.
She's slightly pink so she might have been Pink Diamond's she would have been able to get close,she loves Rose Quartz and supports her cause so why wouldn't she want to shatter pink? We don't know her old owner after all,wouldn't it be an awesome reveal to have her be pinks? it would be a reason for not revealing it in an episode in an earlier season.
She's the leader of homeworld,the unseen big bad,she might have shattered Pink for homeworld's own good.However there's an interesting theory about her having mind control,could she have possibly made one of the diamonds do it,maybe Blue Diamond? Then made all her subjects including Blue Diamond think Rose Quartz shattered her with her sword.It would make Blue's comment make a lot more sense and White Diamond would have had the reasoning that she was doing what was right for her subjects.Then again it would be kinda lazy to make an character not yet seen the one to shatter Pink Diamond.
What do you guys think?
Please tell us why you'd like to report this post
Official fan girl of
wings of fire
#Love is Love